CW Pakistan
  • Legacy
    • Legacy Editorial
    • Editor’s Note
  • Academy
  • Wired
  • Cellcos
  • PayTech
  • Business
  • Ignite
  • Digital Pakistan
  • PSEB
    • DFDI
    • Indus AI Week
  • PASHA
    • CEC Elections 2026
  • TechAdvisor
  • GamePro
  • Partnerships
  • PCWorld
  • Macworld
  • Infoworld
  • TechAdvisor
0
0
0
0
0
Subscribe
CW Pakistan
CW Pakistan CW Pakistan
  • Legacy
    • Legacy Editorial
    • Editor’s Note
  • Academy
  • Wired
  • Cellcos
  • PayTech
  • Business
  • Ignite
  • Digital Pakistan
  • PSEB
    • DFDI
    • Indus AI Week
  • PASHA
    • CEC Elections 2026
  • TechAdvisor
  • GamePro
  • Partnerships
  • Global Insights

NYT Urges Judge To Sanction OpenAI Over Evidence

  • July 13, 2026
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0
Share
Tweet
Share
Share
Share
Share
Follow the SPIN IDG Whatsapp ChannelAdd CW Pakistan as a trusted source on Google

The New York Times, the Daily News, and more than a dozen other media organisations have filed a motion in a Manhattan federal court asking a judge to impose sanctions on OpenAI, escalating a legal fight over artificial intelligence and copyright that could shape the future of a struggling news industry. The publishers allege the ChatGPT maker withheld and destroyed evidence central to what could become a landmark copyright infringement trial over how OpenAI and its business partner Microsoft built their AI systems using millions of news articles.

At the heart of the complaint is an allegation that OpenAI misled the court for roughly two years by claiming it lacked the ability to search its training datasets and ChatGPT output logs for copyrighted material, a claim the publishers say was false. The allegation surfaced after a court ordered deposition of OpenAI data privacy engineer Vinnie Monaco, who reportedly revealed that OpenAI had already conducted internal searches of its training corpus for copyrighted journalism and had amassed a database of around 78 million de-identified ChatGPT conversations well before the news organisations filed suit. The publishers also allege OpenAI implemented an internal tool called Project Giraffe, using a filtering system to detect and record when its outputs reproduced original content, shortly after the lawsuit began, without disclosing this to the court.

Ian Crosby, lead attorney for the Times, said in a statement that OpenAI lied to the Times, the Daily News plaintiffs, the public, and the court, arguing that if the company genuinely believed its use of the publishers’ journalism was fair and legal, it would not have concealed the truth about the searches it had already conducted. Steven Lieberman, an attorney representing the Daily News and several sister publications, said OpenAI had been making misrepresentations for two years about its ability to search for copyrighted content within its systems. The publishers are asking the court to bar OpenAI from relying on a limited sample of chat logs it had negotiated down from an original request of 120 million logs to 20 million, to treat as established fact that fuller logs would have shown substantial reproduction of their content, and to award attorney fees covering their efforts to obtain the withheld evidence.

OpenAI has denied the allegations. Company spokesperson Drew Pusateri said in a statement that as the Times’ case weakens and the publisher has been forced to drop certain claims, it is persisting with efforts to invade the privacy of users unconnected to the case through what he described as blatantly false allegations, adding that the company will continue defending user privacy and long established fair use principles.

The Times originally sued OpenAI and Microsoft in late 2023, becoming the first major news organisation to bring legal action against a generative AI company over alleged copyright violations, and has since been joined by other publishers including MediaNews Group titles, the Center for Investigative Reporting, and Ziff Davis. The Times has spent more than 28 million dollars fighting AI companies in court to date, according to regulatory filings, a figure that includes a separate lawsuit against AI search company Perplexity. The case forms part of a broader wave of AI copyright litigation working through US courts, with OpenAI rival Anthropic having already agreed to pay 1.5 billion dollars to settle a similar case brought by book authors, while a growing number of publishers have instead opted to sign licensing deals with OpenAI, Google, and Meta rather than pursue litigation.

Source

Follow the SPIN IDG WhatsApp Channel for updates across the Smart Pakistan Insights Network covering all of Pakistan’s technology ecosystem.

Share
Tweet
Share
Share
Share
Related Topics
  • ChatGPT
  • copyright lawsuit
  • Microsoft
  • New York Times
  • OpenAI
Previous Article
  • Wired

Pakistan Plans Own OTT Streaming Platform While in Talks With Netflix

  • July 13, 2026
Read More
Next Article
  • GamePro

Pokemon Go Celebrates 10 Years With Times Square Raid

  • July 13, 2026
Read More
You May Also Like
Read More
  • Global Insights

TikTok Launches Deepfake Detection Tool For Public Figures Ahead Of European Elections

  • CWPakistan
  • November 21, 2026
Read More
  • Global Insights

Wired Report Examines Silicon Valley Donations To Polish Visegrad24 Social Media Account

  • CWPakistan
  • November 20, 2026
Read More
  • Global Insights

OmniOps Launches Bunyan Inference Hub For Saudi Hosted AI Models And Compute

  • CWPakistan
  • November 17, 2026
Read More
  • GamePro
  • Global Insights

Original Grand Theft Auto Creators Have Not Played GTA 6 Ahead Of Launch, Says Co-Creator Dave Jones

  • CWPakistan
  • November 16, 2026
Read More
  • Global Insights

SpaceX Catches Upper Stage Of Starship Rocket With Launch Tower Arms For The First Time After 22-Hour Test Flight

  • CWPakistan
  • November 16, 2026
Read More
  • Global Insights

Italy Fines Meta 805 Million Euros Over Facebook Android Photo Gallery Access Without Specific Consent

  • CWPakistan
  • November 16, 2026
Read More
  • Global Insights

Microsoft Says Global 365 Outage Is Not Linked to FAA Ground Stop in United States

  • CWPakistan
  • November 14, 2026
Read More
  • Global Insights

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Steps Down as Colette Kress Takes Over as Interim Chief Executive

  • CWPakistan
  • November 13, 2026
Trending Posts
  • Pakistan Introduces PTA Approval And Interior Clearance For Camera-Enabled Smart Glasses Imports
    • November 21, 2026
  • PTA Inspects 226 Mobile Sites Across 16 Locations, Taking Cumulative Field Monitoring Past 1,127 Sites
    • November 21, 2026
  • Pakistan And ASEAN Agree To Deepen Cooperation On Cyber Threats And Digital Integration
    • November 21, 2026
  • Pakistan Digital Authority Holds Workshop On Digitising Merchant Lending And Registration With Banks, Fintechs And SMEDA
    • November 21, 2026
  • Punjab To Train 25,898 Public School Teachers In AI From November 23
    • November 21, 2026
about
CWPK Legacy
Launched in 1967 internationally, ComputerWorld is the oldest tech magazine/media property in the world. In Pakistan, ComputerWorld was launched in 1995. Initially providing news to IT executives only, once CIO Pakistan, its sister brand from the same family, was launched and took over the enterprise reporting domain in Pakistan, CWPK has emerged as a holistic technology media platform reporting everything tech in the country. It remains the oldest continuous IT publishing brand in the country and in 2025 is set to turn 30 years old, which will be its biggest benchmark and a legacy it hopes to continue for years to come. CWPK is part of the SPIN/IDG Wakhan media umbrella.
Read more
Explore Computerworld Sites Globally
  • computerworld.es
  • computerworld.com.pt
  • computerworld.com
  • cw.no
  • computerworldmexico.com.mx
  • computerwoche.de
  • computersweden.idg.se
  • computerworld.hu
Content from other IDG brands
  • PCWorld
  • Macworld
  • Infoworld
  • TechAdvisor
CW Pakistan CW Pakistan
  • CWPK
  • CXO
  • DEMO
  • WALLET

CW Media & all its sub-brands are copyrighted to SPIN-IDG Wakhan Media Inc., the publishing arm of NCC-RP Group. This site is designed by Crunch Collective. ©️1995-2026. Read Privacy Policy.

Input your search keywords and press Enter.