The NADRA mobile application has come under scrutiny after users identified a strange and controversial feature that appears to let individuals cancel their own identity card on the grounds of death. The service, titled “Cancel Identity Due to Death,” presents two options within the app—one for relatives of the deceased and another labeled “Myself.” The latter option has sparked widespread confusion, as it prompts applicants to undergo a liveness facial recognition check, a process specifically designed to verify that the user is alive and corresponds with official records. The contradiction between the service description and the verification process has raised questions about how a deceased individual could possibly access the app, initiate the request, and pass biometric authentication.
According to NADRA, the feature was never intended to be used by individuals for their own cases of death, but rather by relatives reporting the passing of a family member. A NADRA spokesperson confirmed that the service is meant solely for dependents or relatives who need to officially cancel the deceased’s national identity card. However, the inclusion of a “Myself” option has left many puzzled. Critics argue that such a design oversight not only undermines the seriousness of the service but also highlights broader issues of poor planning, lack of usability testing, and weak quality assurance processes in critical public-facing government apps.
The controversy has amplified ongoing concerns regarding the reliability and clarity of government digital services in Pakistan. NADRA’s app is widely used for key identity-related services, including ID renewals, verification, and updates. Yet, incidents like this draw attention to gaps in user experience and design that could erode public confidence in digitization initiatives. Pakistan has prioritized expanding digital governance as part of its national transformation agenda, but frequent reports of technical errors, confusing interfaces, and inconsistent service delivery continue to surface. This latest episode has reignited debate around the need for stronger oversight in the development of applications that play a vital role in citizens’ access to state services.
While NADRA has attempted to clarify the intention behind the feature, many argue that such flaws reflect a lack of careful review before rolling out new functions. For users, the existence of a “Cancel My Own Identity Due to Death” button is not just confusing but potentially damaging for trust in digital systems that manage something as sensitive and crucial as national identity. Observers believe this controversy serves as another reminder of why government technology platforms require greater transparency, thorough testing, and feedback mechanisms to ensure that digital solutions are both effective and intuitive.
Follow the SPIN IDG WhatsApp Channel for updates across the Smart Pakistan Insights Network covering all of Pakistan’s technology ecosystem.
