The Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) has recovered Rs495 million in penalties from Long Distance International operators in the long-standing International Clearing House (ICH) case. The enforcement action follows a ruling by the Competition Appellate Tribunal, which upheld CCP’s earlier decision against the ICH arrangement. According to CCP’s statement, the recovery includes Rs458 million from Pakistan Telecommunication Company Limited (PTCL) and Rs37 million from Link Dot Net. The case, dating back to 2012, marked one of the most significant competition law interventions in the telecom sector and has now reached its enforcement stage with these financial recoveries.
The dispute arose from the creation of the ICH agreement, under which all incoming international calls were routed exclusively through a PTCL-controlled gateway. Termination rates were fixed at 8.8 US cents per minute, more than four times the rate that had previously prevailed. By eliminating competition and standardizing the rates, the arrangement significantly inflated the cost of overseas calls to Pakistan. This led to windfall revenues for the participating operators, reportedly increasing their income by more than 300 percent, while limiting choices and raising expenses for consumers abroad who needed to connect with Pakistan. CCP had declared the arrangement illegal and anti-competitive, holding that it undermined market competition and allowed operators to exploit consumers.
Initially, CCP had imposed penalties equal to 7.5 percent of each operator’s annual turnover as punishment for their involvement in the ICH. However, after a review, the Competition Appellate Tribunal revised the fines, reducing them to 2 percent of revenues specifically generated from ICH operations. The Tribunal emphasized that operators must still face accountability for their role in the collusive scheme and directed them to deposit the penalties within 30 days. The recovery from PTCL and Link Dot Net marks compliance with this directive and underscores CCP’s determination to ensure that anti-competitive practices are not tolerated in Pakistan’s telecom industry.
CCP Chairman Dr. Kabir Sidhu reaffirmed the Commission’s stance on strict enforcement of competition law in sectors where collusion and market manipulation can harm consumers and the economy. He stressed that while business forums and industry collaborations may have value for sharing knowledge and enhancing efficiency, they must never be misused to coordinate pricing or restrict competition. Dr. Sidhu also issued a clear warning against market abuse, manipulation, consumer exploitation, and similar practices that reduce efficiency and increase costs in key industries like telecom. The recovery in the ICH case is being viewed as a significant signal that operators will face tangible financial consequences for anti-competitive behavior, reinforcing CCP’s broader mission of maintaining fair markets across Pakistan.
Follow the SPIN IDG WhatsApp Channel for updates across the Smart Pakistan Insights Network covering all of Pakistan’s technology ecosystem.
