On a busy day in northern Nigeria, Marian Shammah visited Sabon Gari Market, one of the largest electronics hubs in Kano state, hoping to buy an affordable refrigerator. The 34 year old cleaner, struggling with rising costs and limited income, opted for a second hand appliance priced at 50,000 naira. Within a month, the freezer stopped working and her food spoiled, forcing her back into the market to search for another option. Like many Nigerians, Shammah believed used appliances imported from Europe or America would last longer than new ones available locally. However, her experience reflects a broader trend where second hand imports often fail quickly, adding to growing electronic waste challenges across the country. Observers say Nigeria has become a key destination for discarded electronics from developed nations, many of which are nearing the end of their lifecycle or already damaged, contributing to an expanding environmental and public health concern.
Approximately 60,000 tonnes of used electronics enter Nigeria annually through major ports, with at least 15,700 tonnes already damaged upon arrival, according to United Nations estimates. A tracking study found that over 85 percent of these imports originated from countries including Germany, United Kingdom, Belgium, Netherlands, Spain, China, United States, and Republic of Ireland. While trade in used electronics is allowed under certain conditions, critics say many shipments violate the Basel Convention, an international treaty regulating cross border movement of hazardous waste. Across West Africa, countries including Benin, Ivory Coast, Ghana, Liberia, and Nigeria collectively generate between 650,000 and one million tonnes of e waste each year. Many imported appliances contain hazardous substances such as mercury or outdated refrigerants including R 12 and R 22, chemicals banned in Europe and United States due to their links to ozone depletion and long term health risks. Informal recyclers often dismantle devices without protective equipment, exposing themselves to toxic fumes and heavy metals while earning as little as 3,500 to 14,000 naira weekly. Health surveys among communities near dumping sites report chronic headaches, breathing problems, miscarriages, and neurological symptoms linked to prolonged exposure to toxic materials.
Despite regulations, demand for affordable electronics continues to drive the trade. Vendors at Sabon Gari Market advertise imported appliances as durable and budget friendly, attracting households and small business owners affected by inflation. Many customers acknowledge the risks but still prefer second hand goods due to cost constraints. Traders admit that appliances often arrive untested and are sold without warranties, leaving buyers responsible when products fail. Some shipments enter Nigeria labelled as personal belongings or second hand household goods, limiting detailed inspections at ports. Exporters gather discarded equipment from homes, offices, hotels, and hospitals across Europe, sometimes mixing functional and faulty items in the same containers. Environmental analysts say such practices allow exporters to avoid expensive recycling costs while shifting environmental burdens to developing countries. Weak inspection systems, mislabelling, and gaps in enforcement further complicate regulation, allowing ageing products to continue entering local markets.
Importers and retailers estimate that between 20 and 40 percent of electronics arrive with faults or develop issues shortly after purchase. Broken appliances are frequently discarded in streets or informal dumps, increasing environmental hazards. Experts and advocacy groups are calling for stronger border inspections, certified testing systems, and policies requiring producers and exporters to take financial responsibility for waste. Until stricter measures are implemented, consumers like Shammah remain caught between affordability and reliability. Returning to Sabon Gari Market after her purchase failed, she considered saving longer to buy a new appliance from a certified shop, hoping to avoid further financial losses.
Follow the SPIN IDG WhatsApp Channel for updates across the Smart Pakistan Insights Network covering all of Pakistan’s technology ecosystem.
