• Legacy
  • Academy
  • Business
  • PayTech
  • Ignite
  • Cellcos
  • Wired
  • CovidTech
  • Library
  • Touch Base
Subscribe
CW Pakistan

Computerworld Pakistan

CW Pakistan
  • Legacy
  • Academy
  • Business
  • PayTech
  • Ignite
  • Cellcos
  • Wired
  • CovidTech
  • Library
  • Touch Base
  • Computerworld

The .AI Life

  • March 16, 2017
  • Content Desk
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0

AI learned to betray others. Here’s why that’s okay

There’s been a lot of buzz about some experiments at DeepMind that study whether AI systems will be aggressive or collaborative when playing a game. Players gather virtual apples; they have the ability to temporarily incapacitate an opponent by “shooting” a virtual “laser.” And humans are surprised that AIs at times decide that it’s to their advantage to shoot their opponent, rather than peacefully gathering apples.

My question is simple: what does this tell us? The answer is also simple: nothing at all. If you ask an AI to play a game in which firing lasers at your opponents is allowed, it isn’t surprising that the AI fires lasers at opponents, whether the opponents are virtual or physical. You wouldn’t expect it to a priori develop some version of Asimov’s laws and say, “I can’t do this.” (If the software doesn’t allow it to fire the lasers, well, it won’t, but that’s hardly interesting.) You wouldn’t expect an AI to have a crisis of conscience and say, “no, no, I can’t do it.” Unless it was programmed with some sort of guilt module, which as far as I know, doesn’t exist.

Humans, after all, do the same. They kill in first-person shooters as well as in real life. We have whole divisions of the government devoted to the organized killing of other people. (We ironically call that “keeping the peace.”) And while humans have a guilt module, it usually only engages after the fact.

The only interesting question that a game like this might answer is whether AI systems are more, or less, willing to pull the trigger than humans. I would be willing to bet that:

  • When computers play humans, the computers win. We’ve certainly had enough experience losing at chess, Go, and poker.
  • Humans are more likely to go for the guns because, well, it’s what we do. DeepMind’s research suggests that a computer would only shoot if it’s part of an efficient strategy for winning; it won’t shoot because it’s a reflex, because it’s scared, or because it’s fun.

It’s up to you whether shooting as part of an efficient strategy for winning is an improvement over human behavior, but it’s exactly what I would expect. DeepMind didn’t beat Lee Sedol at Go by refusing to be aggressive.

And even then, given that we’re only talking about a game, I’m not sure that experiment shows us anything at all. I’d expect an AI to be pretty good at playing a first-person shooter, and I don’t see any reason for it to derive Asimov’s Laws from first principles when it’s only exterminating bits. I certainly wouldn’t volunteer to participate in a real-life shooter against some scary Boston Dynamics creation, and I hope nobody plans to run that experiment.

Likewise, I don’t see any reason for an AI to “learn” that there are things in its universe that aren’t just bits. We are fascinated by “machine learning”; but in the end, the machines only learn what we tell them to learn. I’m skeptical of singularities, but I will agree that we’re facing a singularity when a computer can learn, entirely on its own, that some of the bit patterns coming in through its sensors are humans, and that these bit patterns are qualitatively different from the bit patterns of dogs, cats, or rocks.

In the end, we’re back where we started. Fear of AI reflects our fear of ourselves. AI mimics human behaviors because we teach it to do so—in this case, by asking it to play a game with human rules. As I’ve said, if we want better AI, we have to be better people. If we want an AI that can distinguish between humans and bits, we have to teach it what humans are, and how to behave differently in their presence. (“You can shoot the wolf; you can’t shoot the human.”) And if don’t want AI agents to shoot at all, we have to build software that doesn’t have the ability to shoot.

Don’t give your AIs guns.

This article was originally published on the WEF website by Mike Loukides and can be accessed here. 

Total
0
Shares
Share 0
Tweet 0
Pin it 0
Related Topics
  • AI
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Computer World Pakistan
  • Google Deep Mind
  • IDG Pakistan
  • machine learning
  • Mike Loukides
  • WEF
  • World Economic Forum
Content Desk

Previous Article
  • CIO
  • News

Samba Bank Implements New Temenos Core Banking Software

  • March 15, 2017
  • Content Desk
View Post
Next Article
  • Computerworld

University of Peshawar Hosts Science Expo

  • March 16, 2017
  • Sub Editor
View Post
You May Also Like
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • Ignite

The government plans to build a software technology park in Bannu.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • Ignite

The economy is booming: Bags from Pakistan Top ten rankings in terms of improving the business climate

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite

Shafqat Mahmood, Minister of Education, Launches IBCC E-Portal And Mobile App For Education Sector

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

The Board of Investment has launched an online portal for Special Economic Zones.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

Teachers in Punjab now have access to an electronic transfer system.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

Shibli Faraz reports on PSQCA’s plans to launch an automated system to speed up the standardisation process.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

SBP Simplifies the Process of Increasing Overseas Investment for Startups

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

PTCL and GCU have signed an agreement to provide premium ICT services.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • CIO
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

Punjab’s Minister of Higher Education and Information Technology officially launches e-Earn, the province’s largest co-working network.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

Punjab’s Minister of Higher Education and Information Technology officially launches e-Earn, the province’s largest co-working network.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

Quetta will get its first and largest software technology park after a memorandum of understanding is inked.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

Pakistan is one of 15 countries where e-waste poses a serious health risk, according to the United Nations.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite

Pakistan’s NFT Revolution is led by Wasim Akram.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

Pakistan has over 40 fintech companies, according to a report.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • News
  • Technology

Pakistan’s own encrypted messaging software is 60% complete, according to a report.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite

Pakistan’s e-Learning portal, Skills Todo, is still in second place.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

PSEB will create an office in Quetta to help the IT sector in Balochistan grow

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Technology

Pakistani scientists have been praised for developing the ZECC technology for storing fruits and vegetables

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Partnerships
  • Technology

M&P signs an agreement with the National Institute of Financial Technology (NIFT) to enable digital payments on its ‘APPTAK Platform.’

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022
View Post
  • Computerworld
  • DEMO PAKISTAN
  • Ignite
  • Partnerships
  • Technology

LUMS collaborates with Northumbria University and leading UK scientists to create long-term solutions.

  • Sub Editor
  • April 15, 2022

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

about
About
Launched in 1967 internationally, Computerworld Magazine is the oldest tech magazine/media property brand in the world. Today Computerworld (abbreviated as CW) is an ongoing decades old professional publication which in 2014 "went digital”. In Pakistan Computerworld was launched in 1995. Initially providing news to IT executives only, once CIO Pakistan from the same family launched, and took over the domain, CW Pakistan has slowly emerged as a holistic technology news platform reporting everything tech in the country. It remains the oldest running continuous IT media publishing platform in the country and approaching 3 decades of existence, it has been the industry’s biggest benchmark and hopes to continue for years to come.
Read more
Explore Computerworld Sites Globally
  • ComputerWorld.es
  • computerworld.com.pt
  • Computerworld.com
  • cw.no
  • computerworldmexico.com.mx
  • computerwoche.de
  • computersweden.idg.se
  • computerworld.hu
  • cwi.it
  • project.nikkeibp.co.jp
Content from other IDG brands
  • PCWorld
  • Macworld
  • Infoworld
  • TechHive
  • GameStar
  • Network world
CW Pakistan
  • CWPK
  • CXO
  • WALLET
  • Demo
CW Media & all its sub brands are copyrighted to SPIN-IDG Wakhan Media Inc., the publishing arm of NCC-RP Group. Site is designed by Crunch Collective ©️ 2022

Input your search keywords and press Enter.