PTA has rejected a government order to disable SIM cards of over half a million people who haven’t filed income tax returns. PTA argues the order lacks legal basis and could disrupt essential services.
FBR issued the order this week, aiming to pressure non-filers into compliance. It was the first significant action taken after previous reminders and tax notices failed to yield results.
However, PTA claims FBR’s order doesn’t fall under their jurisdiction and wouldn’t be legally binding. They recommend alternative methods like awareness campaigns and SMS reminders instead of resorting to blocking SIM cards.
PTA also raised concerns about the order’s potential impact on social norms, as many SIM cards are registered under male heads of households, potentially disrupting communication for women and children. Additionally, they fear the move could discourage foreign investment and hinder digital transformation efforts.
FBR maintains they consulted PTA before issuing the order and insists telecom companies are responsible for blocking SIM cards under the regulator’s guidance.
This disagreement marks a setback for the government’s plan to broaden the tax base. Currently, less than 4.5 million people file income tax returns, far below the desired 6 million target for this year.
