Italy’s data protection authority, known as the Garante, has fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million, about $887 million, over a feature in the Facebook app for Android that used photos and videos from users’ phone galleries without specific consent. The authority announced the decision on Saturday, November 14, and said that Meta accessed photos, videos, and related metadata stored on the smartphones of Italian users without obtaining specific consent and without properly informing them. The fine equals about 0.47 percent of the global turnover of the group, and it is among the largest that an Italian authority has imposed on a technology company. The Garante counted around 20 million Android users in Italy.
The feature at the centre of the case is called Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook, and it shows photos and videos stored on a phone as suggestions for content to post while a person browses the app. The Garante found that the feature was enabled by default and that Facebook asked for gallery access through a single permission that covered several functions of the app with different purposes. It said this breached Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, which puts the European Union ePrivacy Directive into Italian law and requires free and informed consent before information stored on a device can be accessed. The authority took into account the number of people affected, the duration of the violation, a previous decision against Meta in 2019, and what it described as the limited cooperation of the company during the investigation.
The decision requires Meta to make changes within 60 days. The company must ask users in Italy for separate and specific consent for the feature and must turn it off by default, and it must report to the Garante within 30 days on the steps that it has started and within 90 days on the measures that it has adopted. The authority said that the violation is still continuing for users who have not updated the app. Android users who want to check the access that Facebook has on their own phones can review it in the permissions section of the settings of the phone, under the Facebook app, where the access to photos and videos can be changed or withdrawn.
Meta has said that it will appeal and has called the fine disproportionate. A company spokesperson said that the feature is a simple one that helps people post photos and videos to Facebook, that it works only after users give permission on their device, and that people can change this permission at any time in their settings. The Garante rejected the argument that a single device permission was enough, since the rules in question require specific consent for each purpose, and it also noted that the ePrivacy rules do not provide for the one-stop-shop mechanism that Meta relied upon in its arguments. The decision applies to Italian users of the Android app and adds to a series of cases in Europe in which privacy regulators have examined how Meta handles personal data.
Follow the SPIN IDG WhatsApp Channel for updates across the Smart Pakistan Insights Network covering all of Pakistan’s technology ecosystem.